Recent Reviews
Search for a specific review
RY3 Cigar Blend
A rich, dessert-style rye packed with chocolate, cherry, and candy sweetness. Our RY3 Cigar Blend review breaks down the nose, palate, finish, MSRP value, and how this Cask Strength release stacks up.
RY3 16 Year Light Whiskey
A deep dive into this 16-year-old light whiskey, featuring funfetti cake sweetness, syrupy texture, and aged complexity—see if this $100 bottle is worth adding to your bar.
Wilderness Trail Rye
This Wilderness Trail Rye Bottled-in-Bond review covers its sweet, fruity nose and lighter palate with notes of caramel, honey, and spice. A solid rye whiskey at its MSRP.
Woodford Reserve Rye
Get the full review of Woodford Reserve Rye—a light, easy-drinking whiskey with a few surprises. See how it holds up at its MSRP and if it's worth picking up on your next liquor store visit.
Michter’s 10-Year Rye
This review highlights Michter’s 10-Year Rye—a premium, limited-release whiskey with an unforgettable nose, seasonal spice, and a steep $200 MSRP. Is it worth the price? Find out.
Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye
Explore our in-depth review of Michter’s Barrel Strength Rye—a limited release packed with sweet cinnamon, vanilla, and rye spice. Is it worth the premium MSRP? Read more to find out.
A Midwinter Nights Dram
Is Act 7, Scene 4 one of the last great A Midwinter Night’s Dram? We break down the nose, palate, and finish — and why this MGP release stands above the newer bottles. Don’t grab another bottle before reading this.
Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye
Is Jack Daniel’s Single Barrel Barrel Proof Rye really a rye—or just a high-proof bourbon in disguise? Does the bold banana and cherry profile live up to the hype? What’s the value at its MSRP or on sale? Find out in this in-depth whiskey review.
E. H. Taylor Straight Rye
Read our E.H. Taylor Straight Rye review to explore its sweet candy notes, subtle rye spice, and light oak finish. Find out if this Colonel-approved bottle at its MSRP or sale price is worth adding to your collection.
Old Carter Rye
Old Carter Rye (Batch 11) provides a bold and flavorful rye whiskey that lives up to the hype. From its rye bread and cherry pie nose to its silky fig newton palate, find out if it's worth the $200+ MSRP or even paying secondary.
Frank August Winter Cover Rye
A 3 barrel batch release with a unique bubblegum sweetness, subtle rye spice, and a buttery mouthfeel. At an MSRP of $125, does this Case Study 3 rye justify its price?
Michter’s Toasted Rye
A $130 MSRP bottle delivering exceptional complexity with notes of vanilla custard, s’mores, and toasted marshmallow. Discover why this rye is worth its price and is perfect for special occasions.
Barrel King - Batch 12 (Cara-Coconut Apple)
With an MSRP over $100, does the caramel, coconut, and apple finish for Barrel King Batch 12 shine through? Explore the unique tasting notes, including toasted marshmallow and a red apple palate, and find out if this high-proof whiskey is worth the price or best found on sale.
Elijah Craig Toasted Rye
Learn how the Elijah Craig Toasted Rye provides sweet orange notes, subtle rye spice, and a toasted oak profile to create a satisfying pour. Is this 94-proof rye whiskey a great value at its MSRP? Or should you search for something else?
Sagamore Spirit Rye Double Oak
At an approachable $55-60 MSRP, this rye whiskey offers a delightful mix of sweet cherry cola, rye spice, and subtle wood notes, with a smooth finish featuring hints of caramel and butterscotch. Perfect for rye lovers and those new to the category.
Seismic Rye
Dive into the unique flavors of Seismic Rye Single Barrel in our detailed review. Is this $80+ rye whiskey worth the price? We explore its profile, from sweet cherries to rye spice, and share whether it's a good buy for your collection.
Willett Rye (4-Year)
Read our review of Willett 4-Year Rye. How does this $60 MSRP rye whiskey compare to others in the same price range? Is it the perfect starter rye or just another average pour? Find out now!
Templeton Midnight Rye
Is Templeton Midnight Rye a $35 port-finished whiskey that rivals A Midwinter Night's Dram, or is it a gimmick that will leave you frustrated? Read our review to find out if this rye lives up to the hype or falls flat.
Bardstown Origin Rye
Read our comprehensive review of Bardstown Origin Series Rye. How much do those rye flavors come through? Does it compare to the Origin Series Bourbon? The answers might surprise you!
Sazerac Rye
Interested in finding your next budget pour? Sazerac Rye may be the bottle for you. While not the most complex pour, this whiskey review will highlight the areas where this rye shines!